Rate this post

Turkey is a fantastic meat and one of the most popular leftovers in the world! A truly traditional leftover turkey sandwich includes cheese and cranberry sauce, as well as whatever other tasty food you have on hand. What kind of cheese pairs best with turkey? You’ve worked hard for many hours on your turkey, so you don’t want to serve it with just any old cheese! Let’s examine which cheeses go best with a turkey sandwich. If you’ve never tried a turkey sandwich before, this is the place to start. You could even discover your new favorite sandwich combo!

Hey there! This site is reader-supported and I earn commissions if you purchase products from retailers after clicking on a link from this site.

What Is The Best Cheese To Go In A Turkey Sandwich?

Cheese is usually an important component of most sandwiches in my opinion. The kind of cheese you use also has an impact on how wonderful the sandwich is, and depending on the other toppings you have, certain cheeses mix particularly well with specific toppings.

The following is a list of the greatest cheeses for a turkey sandwich, as well as the best components to go with each cheese!

Which is the greatest cheese for a turkey sandwich, without further ado?

Gouda Cheese

Gouda cheese complements a turkey sandwich beautifully since the taste is modest but the texture is creamy. Aged gouda has a saltier taste and a firmer texture. If you choose a milder gouda, it will melt into your turkey sandwich a little more.

With a caramel, butterscotch taste, gouda gives a slight amount of sweetness to your sandwich without dominating the other flavors. It’s a great addition to a smoked turkey sandwich since the sweetness complements the smokiness of the turkey.

Salami is another great addition to a gouda cheese and turkey sandwich. Gouda, like smoked turkey, complements the smokiness of the salami. Another great addition to your cheese and turkey sandwich is smoked gouda.

Buy on Amazon

Cheddar Cheese

If you want a stronger-flavored cheese, cheddar is an excellent choice for a smoked turkey sandwich.

A juicy turkey sandwich benefits from the dry, crumbly texture of vintage cheddar. The rich tangy taste, along with a nutty undertone, perfectly complements the smokiness of smoked turkey.

A turkey avocado sandwich mixes beautifully with aged cheddar. Cheddar is also an excellent choice for youngsters’ lunches.

Buy on Amazon

Brie Cheese

Brie is a traditional cheese combo that works well in a turkey sandwich with cheese and cranberry sauce.

This is a soft cheese with a texture comparable to camembert cheese. It has a tart fruity taste that goes nicely with cranberry sauce.

Because of its watery nature, this sandwich might get a touch soggy if not properly wrapped. Brie also goes well with avocado and turkey sandwiches, and it tastes great with dijon mustard.

Buy on Amazon

Emmental Cheese

Emmental is a mild cheese that goes well with turkey sandwiches. This cheese is excellent for grilled sandwiches and will most likely fulfill your demands for grilled turkey sandwiches.

Because of its sweet and complex flavor, Emmental works well in cold turkey sandwiches. It features hazelnut and ripe fruit overtones that complement the mild taste of turkey.

Buy on Amazon

Swiss Cheese

Swiss cheese has a nutty flavor with a smooth, creamy texture. This tastes fantastic.

Naturally, swiss cheese is an excellent accompaniment to turkey sandwiches. Particularly if you’re searching for a turkey meat combo to feed your kids!

Buy on Amazon

Gruyere Cheese

Gruyere is a hard cheese that has been matured for many months. Its taste is significantly dependant on its age. The longer gruyere cheese is kept, the more earthy its taste becomes.

Sandwiches with Gruyere cheese and turkey will have a strong flavor and may need extra salt and pepper to bring out the dry flavor. Bean sprouts go well with a gruyere cheese and turkey sandwich.

This cheese goes well with ham and turkey sandwiches. Its sourness balances out the saltiness and sweetness of the ham while also complementing the turkey well.

Buy on Amazon

Provolone Cheese

Another cheese with a mild nutty taste is provolone. But, unlike other cheeses, it has a somewhat peppery taste. Since it is mild, it makes an excellent sandwich cheese. Provolone is a popular cheese in Philly cheese steaks.

Provolone has a delicate flavor that does not dominate the similarly delicate chicken. When combined with turkey, the saltiness of provolone adds a sharpness to the sandwich.

Buy on Amazon

Parmesan Cheese

Parmesan, or Parmigiano Reggiano, is a firm Italian cheese. Parmesan cheese has a nutty flavor and tastes sweet, salty, and bitter all at the same time. It’s flaky and grainy, with a light to dark yellow tinge. Because of its long shelf life, Parmesan is a popular cheese.

Parmesan is a mature cheese. As a result, it will provide a powerful flavor to your sandwich. If you wish to prevent this, combine your parmesan with a milder cheese.

Buy on Amazon

Pecorino Romano Cheese

Pecorino Romano cheese is made in Italy from sheep’s milk. This cheese comes in three variants. They all vary from one another based on their age.

Pecorino Romano has a somewhat acidic and nearly peppery taste. The sharper the flavor, the older the Pecorino.

Pecorino Romano is another aged cheese. As a result, it will provide a powerful flavor to your sandwich. If you wish to prevent this, combine your Pecorino Romano with a mild cheese of your choice. You might also try a pecorino alternative to see if it’s more to your liking!

Buy on Amazon

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey jack melts quite well, making it an ideal cheese for a steaming hot turkey sandwich.

It is an all-time favorite American cheese that is ideal for sandwiches. Monterey jack’s naturally sweet, buttery taste complements turkey well in grilled cheese sandwiches. It’s also ideal for making mac & cheese with turkey meatballs.

You’ll definitely like the buttery texture mixed with the neutral turkey flesh!

Buy on Amazon


Another fantastic addition to a turkey sandwich is fresh mozzarella.

Combined with cold shredded turkey on a bed of greens, you may add some broken up fresh mozzarella balls that have been gently seasoned with salt and pepper. This is a delicate yet delicious sandwich that is also fairly nutritious!

Buy on Amazon

Pepper Jack

The spicy flavor of Pepper Jack cheese complements a turkey cheese sandwich well. A high-quality Wisconsin Pepper Jack will have utilized fresh pepper rather than dried pepper, which will make it taste even better!

This will actually impart the pepper’s fruity qualities, which taste fantastic with turkey, especially if you use heated turkey; this will melt well into the sandwich and taste simply delicious.

Buy on Amazon

Turkey Sandwich and Cheese FAQs

What cheese goes best with turkey?

Gouda, Emmental, Swiss, brie, gruyere, provolone, fresh mozzarella, cheddar, Monterey jack, and pepper jack cheese are the finest cheeses to combine with turkey.

What is the best cheese for cold turkey sandwich?

Emmental and mozzarella are both excellent cold turkey sandwich cheeses!

What is the best cheese for smoked turkey sandwich?

Smoked turkey sandwiches benefit from the tastes of gouda and cheddar. You may use them on leftover turkey at any time!

The Best Cheese in a Turkey Sandwich – Answered!

Hopefully, this guide will assist you in determining which cheese is most suited to your taste, ensuring that your next turkey sandwich is the tastiest cheese and turkey sandwich you’ve ever eaten!


What is the best cheese to go with turkey?

Edam and Monterey For starters, Jack and Havarti are excellent options. But for a genuinely elevated turkey, we pick Provolone Dolce.

What are the 4 most popular sandwich cheese?

Sandwich Cheeses – 8 Popular Sandwich Cheeses
Swiss Cheese from Switzerland…. Fontina Cheese from Italy…. Provolone, the Cousin to Fontina…. Gruyere, the Swiss Cousin to Emmental…. Havarti Cheese from Denmark…. Manchego Cheese, the All-Powerful Spanish Cheese…. American Cheese from Right Here in the United States.
More to come…

What cheese goes with smoked turkey breast?

What kind of cheese pairs best with a turkey sandwich? I like the mild, smooth taste of colby jack with the smokiness of the turkey, but any melty cheese would do. This turkey sandwich would also be wonderful with provolone, gouda, mozzarella, Monterey jack, or any other cheese you can think of.

What kind of cheese goes well with peppered turkey?

Savor our mellow Vermont Yellow Cheddar Cheese with spicy Cracked Pepper Mill®Smoked Turkey Breast in this warm, melty sandwich. It’s a hit at every family gathering and takes just minutes to prepare.

What tastes good with turkey?

Easy turkey side dishes
1) Smashed potatoes with bay leaves.
2) Salad with green beans and goat cheese…
3) Grains with Brussels sprouts and speck…
4) Salad with couscous…
5) Rocket cole slaw.
6) A sweet potato and chive damper.
7) Stuffing with honey macadamias.
8) Stuffing with pork.
More to come…

Does mozzarella go well with turkey?

All sandwich lovers, unite! Lettuce, turkey, and mozzarella cheese are layered between bread pieces slathered with a creamy basil and olive spread for Mozzarella Turkey Sandwiches you didn’t know you needed!

What are the top 5 cheeses?

Which are the top five most popular cheeses?
Cheddar is a kind of cheese.
Mozzarella is a kind of cheese.
Parmesan is a kind of cheese.
American Cheddar.
The cream cheese.

Which cheese tastes best in sandwich?

8 Greatest Grilled Cheese Sandwich Cheeses
Cheddar, medium. Raclette, the classic grilled cheese. You’ve probably seen melty cheese being melted and scraped over items like meat, bread, and potatoes.
Mar 23, 2022

Does provolone taste good with turkey?

Thinly sliced deli turkey is sandwiched between the crunchy buttery bread. There’s also sliced provolone cheese, tomato slices, and mayonnaise. This is very amazing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *